Expert Guidance for Your Home Financing Journey

Located conveniently on North McCarthy Road, the Waterstone Mortgage Appleton team has over 50 years of combined experience serving the Fox Valley and Green Bay. Led by Branch Managers Pam Beattie and Jeff Anklam, we don’t just close loans—we build financial strategies. Whether you are a first-time homebuyer looking for WHEDA assistance or a veteran utilizing your VA benefits, our in-house underwriting ensures your loan stays local and closes on time.

250

Clients served every year

11

Team members

Our Vision

Our vision is to be the most trusted and innovative mortgage solutions provider in multiple states. We are dedicated to empowering individuals and families to achieve their dream of homeownership with confidence and ease, making us the go-to mortgage lender in Wisconsin.

Our Mission

Our mission at Waterstone is to build lasting relationships with each client by providing exceptional service and personalized solutions for their home loan needs. We are committed to putting clients first, addressing their concerns with unwavering dedication to customer satisfaction.

Our focus has always been on what truly matters—CLIENTS! This commitment to excellence earned me recognition in SocialSurvey.com’s 2016 Top 25 in Client Satisfaction in the United States, a testament to the incredible support of this company and the trust of our clients.”

Our Commitment to Excellence: Core Values

Integrity

We are dedicated to upholding the highest standards of honesty and transparency in every interaction. Our unwavering commitment to integrity ensures that clients can trust us with their most significant financial decisions, confident that we always prioritize their best interests above all else.

Customer-Centric Approach

Our focus is always on our clients. We are dedicated to understanding and meeting their unique needs, offering personalized service and unwavering support to help them navigate the mortgage process with confidence every step of the way.

Innovation

We are committed to embracing new ideas and technologies to continuously enhance our services. Our innovative approach keeps us at the forefront of the mortgage industry, enabling us to offer efficient, cutting-edge solutions that meet the evolving needs of our clients.

Community Involvement

We are deeply invested in our community, actively participating in and contributing to its growth and development. Our engagement in local initiatives reflects our commitment to making a positive, lasting impact, fostering a stronger and more vibrant community for all.

Meet Our Team

Our philosophy is simple — hire a team of diverse, passionate people and foster a culture that empowers you to do you best work.

Jeff Anklam
Jeff Anklam Branch Manager & Mortgage Broker
Jeff specializes in VA, WHEDA, and conventional loans to help Fox Valley buyers succeed.
NMLS #279966
119 North McCarthy Road, Suite F, Appleton, WI 54913.
+9207505001 / 9203620159
Janklam@waterstonemortgage.com
Pam Beattie
Pam Beattie Branch Manager & Mortgage Broker
Pam brings decades of local lending experience to homebuyers in Appleton and Green Bay building relationships that last far beyond closing day.
NMLS #343340
119 North McCarthy Road, Suite F, Appleton, WI 54913.
+19207505001
pbeattie@waterstonemortgage.com
Jason Heiser
Jason Heiser Loan Officer
Jason is renowned for his "client-first" approach specializing in FHA Loans, Refinancing, and Detailed Financial Breakdowns.
NMLS #10804
119 North McCarthy Road, Suite F, Appleton, WI 54913.
+19207505000
Amy Kaufman
Amy Kaufman Loan Officer
Amy specializes in first-time homebuyers and conventional financing helping families transition from renting to owning.
NMLS #277571
119 North McCarthy Road, Suite F, Appleton, WI 54913.
920.750.5007 / 920.851.5686
AKaufman@WaterstoneMortgage.com
Pam Schubert
Pam Schubert Loan Officer
Pam is dedicated to helping first-time homebuyers and veterans achieve their homeownership dreams.
NMLS #269649
119 North McCarthy Road, Suite F, Appleton, WI 54913.
920.750.7939 / 920.410.2646
PSchubert@WaterstoneMortgage.com
Rylie Schaller
Rylie Schaller Loan Originator
Rylie offers a variety of mortgage solutions, including government loans (FHA and VA), options for first-time homebuyers, and down payment assistance (DPA) programs. .
NMLS #2217996
119 North McCarthy Road, Suite F, Appleton, WI 54913.
920.257.4074 / 920.676.4332
RSchaller@WaterstoneMortgage.com

Tailored Mortgage Solutions to Meet Your Unique Needs

We’re not just a mortgage lender – we’re your trusted partners in making homeownership a reality. With a comprehensive understanding of the Wisconsin market and a dedication to providing personalized service, we’re here to help you find the perfect mortgage solution tailored to your needs. Let us guide you every step of the way towards securing the home of your dreams.

Waterstone Mortgage Corporation – Appleton Branch 119 North McCarthy Road, Suite F, Appleton, WI 54913

Proudly serving homebuyers in Appleton, Green Bay, the Fox Valley, and throughout Wisconsin (Outagamie & Brown Counties).

Core Local Programs: VA Home Loans | WHEDA & First-Time Buyer Grants | FHA | Conventional | USDA financing.Licensing & Compliance: All loan requests are subject to credit approval as well as specific program requirements and guidelines. For some programs, income and property restrictions may apply. Information is subject to change without notice.
Corporate NMLS ID #186434
NMLS Consumer Access
Waterstone Mortgage Corporation (NMLS #186434) is a wholly owned subsidiary of WaterStone Bank SSB (NASDQ: WSBF). © 2026 Waterstone Mortgage Corporation. All rights reserved.© 2026 Waterstone Mortgage Corporation. All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Policy